Executive summary
Many distributors are looking to control costs as they face the combined pressure of rising expenses and expectations. To get costs under control, distributors need to find their own cost control exposures, build the flexibility to gain control, pick the right technology approach and weigh their opportunities to know when to make a move. Incremental improvements and timely technology adoption are critical for maintaining margins in this competitive market.
Every distributor’s costs are rising, along with customer expectations for speed and savings. That leaves distributors stuck in the middle, trying to make the numbers match up.
“We’re seeing a lot of clients focused on cost containment, given the revenue challenges facing this industry,” said Grant Thornton Transportation and Distribution Industry Head Russell Norris. “Controlling costs and predicting costs are of the utmost importance.”
Cost volatility has recently accelerated in some areas, as tariff structures have shifted prices and wait times for parts, containers and other expenses. Companies might be trying to manage these costs across a complex network of assets, territories and distribution centers, especially after mergers and acquisitions.
It’s a complicated equation, but many companies have started making moves in a race for control. To get ahead of it all, start by looking at your cost control exposure.
Find cost control exposure
Look at what’s within your control, what isn’t and how you can prepare. “Start by mapping your exposure to volatility across three key inputs — fuel, containers and parts — because each of these has a different operational fingerprint,” said Grant Thornton Business Consulting Managing Director Brad Hulbert. Each distribution company has different exposure to these input costs, and some companies are already using technology to take control.
- For fuel, companies should look at route density, fuel spending trends and whether they are using hedging or optimization tools. “If you’re not already using AI-powered route optimization to reduce fuel usage across your fleet, that could correlate to millions of dollars in savings,” Hulbert said.
- On the container side, look at cycle times and demurrage fees. AI-driven solutions can track container flows globally, predicting port congestion to help you proactively reroute or reallocate assets before delays cascade.
- For parts, companies might look at maintenance schedules and supplier diversity. “Predictive maintenance is becoming a lot more common across transportation and distribution companies, and it's a real game changer,” Hulbert said. Telematics with AI technology can help predict part failures before they happen, reducing downtime and emergency repair costs. “I saw that with a client that’s managing a small private fleet and really leveraging telematics to determine when things should be repaired — to get ahead of unplanned breakdowns,” Hulbert said.
On the purchasing side, Grant Thornton Business Consulting Senior Manager Domenic Scavola added, “I advise clients to treat their spare parts — and some other items for maintenance, repair and operations — as inventory. Have a good strategy to ensure that, when something does go wrong or fail, you have that part on hand. We’re seeing very long lead times with some parts.”
Once distributors know where they have cost control exposure, and whether they have existing solutions in place, they can look at how to gain more control.
Gain more control
To gain control of costs, most companies need better flexibility across areas like pricing, scenario planning or forecasting.
- Pricing: “A lot of this issue correlates to the ability to have dynamic pricing across organizations, where you can have a fluid pricing structure based on what each company is actually costing you to serve,” Hulbert said. “A lot of companies don’t do this well. They take a blended average and load it into their cost profiles. That can get you in trouble from a pricing perspective.”
- “What often gets lost is that no two orders are the same internal cost to you,” Scavola said, citing factors like order volume, timing and routes that can affect your costs. “The cost to execute doesn’t always make it back to the customer appropriately.” Hulbert said that dynamic pricing requires both data and solutions. “You need that level of data, then layer in where costs are going and bring that back in some form of dynamic pricing. That enables you to mitigate your margin pressure.”
- Scenario planning: Scenario-planning tools can simulate what-if disruptions, and then recommend mitigation strategies. “I really think of this as a digital twin of your supply chain. ‘Digital twin,’ is a term that’s been around for years, but you can embed AI in it for scenario planning,” Hulbert said. With scenario planning, companies can prepare and establish options in advance of cost changes.
- Forecasting: When AI converges with IoT devices, real-time sensors can feed data into systems for budget forecasts, planning, dynamic routing and predictive maintenance. “I’ve seen this firsthand, and it can be very beneficial for organizations,” Hulbert said.
Every distribution company has a unique set of factors to consider for technology solutions, whether they are trying to control costs or recover margin in operations. Once you identify how technology can help, you need a cost-effective approach.
How we can help you
SERVICE
INDUSTRY
Pick the right approach
“Mid-market firms are in a real double bind because they feel volatility as much as the big players, but they don’t have the same resources to mitigate it,” Hulbert said.
Hulbert outlined three ways that firms can be cost-conscious about cost control:
- Modular cloud solutions: Look for modular cloud-based tools that will integrate with your existing systems and won’t require a large IT overhaul. “This is about finding the right technology solution to solve the right problem,” Hulbert said.
- Use case ROI: Start in a high-impact area like predictive maintenance or fuel optimization, demonstrate the benefit, obtain the ROI and then scale from there, Hulbert outlined. “Don’t try to solve all of your problems at once.”
- Price flexibility: Look for flexible pricing models on the solution. “A lot of vendors now offer usage space or subscription pricing, which makes them more accessible,” Hulbert said.
Look for those three things when you’re really trying to determine the right path forward for you, with the money that you have available to spend.
Sometimes, you can expand existing solutions. “A lot of transportation management systems and routing solutions are starting to incorporate AI,” Scavola said. “The key differentiator now is that AI can give us a lot more visibility to bring in external factors that were very difficult to measure before.” That means AI-driven forecasting and other functions can go beyond an organization’s historical data to incorporate information about the market, weather, traffic congestion and other impacts.
With all of the new capabilities, it’s still important to keep the bottom line in mind. “Sometimes it gets lost in the excitement about AI, but you need to make sure that whatever you implement has tangible value that ties back to a cost driver or value driver,” Scavola said. “Even with forecasting, it’s a question of how you were doing before and how you are doing now. Are you actually more accurate, and what's the value of that change?”
As technology capabilities continue to advance, so will your competitors. The key is to find the right solutions to fit your needs and know when to make a move.
Know when to make a move
For companies in any industry, digital transformation takes time. It requires technology and data alignment that will continue to pay off in the future. Fortunately, technology solutions that help control costs, drive growth or achieve other goals can all contribute to your transformation. “You see a wide range of investment in technology and AI across distribution companies,” Norris said. “What I notice is: The companies that previously invested in technology are now able to pivot to some of the AI solutions, and those that had not invested in technology just don't have the capability of doing that yet.”
It's important to be ready to make a move in this competitive environment — and to keep an eye on what others are doing. “It’s always worth monitoring competitors in this industry,” Scavola said. “Everyone is going to be watching each other very closely and, when something looks proven, they’re going to be quick to jump on that. You’re looking for very small edges here, so anything that can give you a half step up on your competitor is a big deal.”
Hulbert agreed, “The little things you can do along the way to really drive that margin improvement, basis point by basis point, are going to set you up for success in a hyper-competitive market like this.” Norris added, “With razor-thin margins, every incremental improvement matters.”
Contacts:
Head of Transportation & Distribution Industry
Grant Thornton Advisors LLC
Principal, Tax Services
Content disclaimer
This Grant Thornton Advisors LLC content provides information and comments on current issues and developments. It is not a comprehensive analysis of the subject matter covered. It is not, and should not be construed as, accounting, legal, tax, or professional advice provided by Grant Thornton Advisors LLC. All relevant facts and circumstances, including the pertinent authoritative literature, need to be considered to arrive at conclusions that comply with matters addressed in this content.
Grant Thornton Advisors LLC and its subsidiary entities are not licensed CPA firms.
For additional information on topics covered in this content, contact a Grant Thornton Advisors LLC professional.
Trending topics
No Results Found. Please search again using different keywords and/or filters.
Share with your network
Share