Executive Summary
Banking CFOs face mounting pressure to drive profitable customer growth while margins compress and competition intensifies. AI represents the fastest route to profitable lead generation — if the organizational foundations are in place.
Most banks are spending at least 11% more on tech like AI this year, according to our Digital Transformation Survey, yet most AI pilots aren't scaling to profitable growth. The issue isn't the technology — it's organizational readiness. Whether it's misaligned metrics between marketing and finance, fragmented data across business lines or pressure to match fintech speed without proper controls, skipping the foundational work means missing ROI later. CFOs who tackle these basics first are seeing AI lead generation deliver profitable customer relationships, not just more leads.
Banking CFOs see the promise of AI. Automation, predictive analytics, machine learning — all promise to streamline operations, reduce acquisition costs and sharpen customer targeting with clearer, faster ROI. Yet, too many institutions aren't realizing these returns.
AI-powered lead generation represents one of the highest-impact opportunities to integrate advanced analytics directly into profitable growth, but most banks struggle to scale models past the pilot stage. The constraint isn't just the AI technology itself — it’s also organizational alignment and the technical infrastructure to support it: ensuring marketing and finance measure the same outcomes, connecting fragmented data systems and building the analytical foundations that turn prospects into profitable relationships.
Why AI lead generation investments are stalling
“Banks aren’t failing to scale AI because the algorithms lack horsepower; they’re failing because no one can prove the algorithms are boosting profit,” said Mark Owens, Grant Thornton Business Consulting Managing Director. Until marketing, finance and risk agree on what ‘winning’ looks like, AI stays stuck in pilot mode.
Team KPIs aren’t aligned
When marketing celebrates lead volume while finance tracks margins, neither side can draw a straight line from AI spend to bottom‑line impact.
That ambiguity keeps CFOs from authorizing further funding, and promising models never scale beyond testing.
“Everyone’s incentives must ladder up to risk‑adjusted profitability,” said Owens. “Until finance and marketing share the same scoreboard, AI will look like cost, not contribution. Evolve scorecards beyond lead counts. Track lifetime profit per borrower, cross‑sell uptake and risk‑adjusted acquisition cost — the metrics that convince a CFO to scale the model.”
Mis‑matched KPIs create data that can’t satisfy the CFO’s ROI test, and AI funding stalls. Align the measures, and the business case for scaling becomes evident.
Fragmented data undermines AI potential
“Data quality is the make-or-break for AI models,” Owens said. “It's garbage in, garbage out.”
Models trained on incomplete datasets target wrong prospects and miss profitable opportunities. They need transaction history, credit utilization patterns and repayment behavior — along with external sources like social media indicators and public records — to identify valuable prospects, but that data often sits in separate systems: credit teams have risk data, marketing tracks campaign performance and finance monitors account profitability. Nearly 40% of banking leaders say their data quality still “needs work,” according to our Digital Transformation Survey.
“Banks sit on a treasure trove of data, but legacy systems trap this intelligence in isolated silos,” said Graham Tasman, Grant Thornton's Head of the Banking Industry. This fragmentation makes it nearly impossible to capture signals around spending changes, declined transactions or digital engagement when data is scattered across product lines and business units.
Three ways to make AI work for lead gen ROI
AI capabilities that drive lead-generation ROI
- Lead-scoring algorithms - Analyze data to predict the likelihood of leads becoming profitable, multi-product customers
- Dynamic campaign optimization - Automatically adjust targeting and messaging based on conversion performance
- Customer intelligence platforms - Combine internal and external data to create comprehensive prospect profiles
- Real-time personalization engines - Customize outreach based on customer behavior and preferences
- Predictive analytics for lifetime value - Estimate total relationship value to guide marketing spend allocation
1. Use AI to target lifetime value
Banks often measure lead-generation success by immediate conversions and single-product acquisition costs, missing the bigger picture of lifetime relationship value.
"Really understanding the cumulative value that comes from cross-products introduced over time is a key component as organizations move beyond simple metrics," said Owens.
Focusing on customer lifetime value means targeting prospects who will generate the most profit across multiple products over years, not just immediate transactions. This shift requires reallocating some marketing budget toward the prospects most likely to become multi-product customers, supported by technology that connects CRM systems with predictive analytics and marketing metrics that track relationship profitability.
2. Lead with complete solutions
When a lead is identified, comprehensive data insights should drive comprehensive positioning from the first conversation, rather than sequential cross-selling efforts.
"That's solution-based selling," explained David Koppy, Grant Thornton Business Consulting Principal. "You want to understand and map out the best entry point and what pathway gives you the greatest probability of long-term success."
Customer intelligence from lead scoring already signals profit potential across multiple products. A commercial real estate financing conversation becomes an integrated discussion including treasury management, private banking services and construction-to-permanent financing options rather than separate sales cycles months apart.
"The segmentation strategy on the front end informs the appropriate bundling of product suites, which ultimately translates to that solution package,” Owens said. Working with business line leaders to create integrated response strategies enables different approaches for different segments — manufacturing prospects receive business lending plus cash management and trade services positioning, while professional services prospects get lending, wealth management and succession planning conversations.
3. Optimize lead generation performance in real-time
Static lead-generation campaigns become outdated quickly, but machine learning algorithms can feed performance data back into targeting and messaging for continuous improvement. Key performance indicators (KPIs) include offer acceptance rates from different lead sources, conversion velocity through the pipeline and uptake patterns across product combinations.
Daily performance dashboards enable automatic testing when conversion rates drop for specific segments — giving you the chance to test different messaging, alternative product positioning or refined audience targeting. Unlike traditional monthly reviews, AI-enabled systems learn from every interaction, making targeting more precise with each prospect who doesn't convert and reinforcing successful patterns across similar customer profiles.
Start here
These diagnostic questions can help evaluate your investments in AI-enabled lead generation:
Audit your measurement alignment: Do marketing and finance track the same customer profitability metrics that align with business goals? If not, establish shared KPIs before expanding AI investments.
Identify your highest-impact data integration: Which data sources, if connected, would most improve lead scoring accuracy? Start there, rather than attempting comprehensive data unification.
Plan for organizational adoption: Budget for role redefinition and process changes alongside technology. Scaling AI lead generation requires relationship managers, marketing teams and finance analysts to work differently — not just use new tools.
Conclusion
CFOs seeking real returns from AI lead generation must focus on organizational fundamentals before chasing technology trends. Success requires proving investments improve loan margins and customer retention, not just lead flow.
"Leaders need to be clear on prioritized use cases within the business," emphasized Koppy. "They need to understand where they can extract the most return and what foundational work sets up AI investment for success."
Contacts:
Partner, Business Consulting
Grant Thornton Advisors LLC
David Koppy is a Partner within the Grant Thornton Business Consulting practice focused on growth strategies.
Bellevue, WA
Industries
- Banking
- Manufacturing, Transportation & Distribution
- Media & Entertainment
- Not-for-profit & Higher Education
- Private Equity
- Services
- Retail & Consumer Brands
- Technology, Media & Telecommunications
Service Experience
- Advisory Services
- Operations and Performance
- Strategy
- Alliances
- Technology Modernization
- Business Consulting
Content disclaimer
This Grant Thornton Advisors LLC content provides information and comments on current issues and developments. It is not a comprehensive analysis of the subject matter covered. It is not, and should not be construed as, accounting, legal, tax, or professional advice provided by Grant Thornton Advisors LLC. All relevant facts and circumstances, including the pertinent authoritative literature, need to be considered to arrive at conclusions that comply with matters addressed in this content.
Grant Thornton Advisors LLC and its subsidiary entities are not licensed CPA firms.
For additional information on topics covered in this content, contact a Grant Thornton Advisors LLC professional.
Trending topics
No Results Found. Please search again using different keywords and/or filters.
Share with your network
Share