Your board of directors should be a powerful strategic asset, yet too many private companies fail to fully understand or realize the potential value of their board. “Many private company boards are stacked with friends or family members,” says Doug Gawrych, national managing partner for Grant Thornton’s private company practice. “Instead, private companies should seek independent and experienced board members who bring the background and insights to help those companies understand their opportunities and risks and then develop and execute the right strategies to drive the business forward.”
To help frame how to make your board more effective, let’s focus on three key areas:
Getting governance right
- Governance and controls
- Technology, innovation and disruption
- Talent and culture
When it comes to governance, private company boards have far more latitude than their public counterparts, which have to comply with the stringent requirements of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX). The good news is that private companies can, therefore, tailor their governance approach more closely to their specific industry and culture. The bad news? At too many private companies, that wider latitude translates into an overly lax or ineffective controls environment.
“Just because they don’t have to comply with SOX doesn’t mean private companies can’t mine it for ideas to apply to their own governance challenges,” says Gawrych. “Public company best practices around governance and internal controls can be tailored to your environment to deliver the oversight you need without a lot of the burdensome compliance minutia that public companies face.” Having at least one board member with a strong accounting and controls background can be a key asset in this effort.
Regulatory compliance is another key governance concern. In its 2018-2019 Private Company Governance Survey, the National Association of Corporate Directors (NACD) reported that 41.5 percent of private companies surveyed consider dealing with changes in the regulatory climate as one of the trends that will most impact their businesses in the next 12 months. The more heavily regulated your industry, the bigger the challenge. Your board should be ensuring that you have an effective and efficient regulatory compliance approach in place. “Many businesses are using AI, machine learning and other automation tools to drive compliance efficiency,” says Gawrych. “Having a board member who is familiar with your regulatory environment and with leading edge practices for addressing it can be a real strength.
In the end, governance isn’t just a matter of compliance, it’s a matter of ethics. Ethics starts with the right culture, and that starts with the tone at the top. From helping to frame a clear code of conduct to serving as impeccable models of the company’s culture, tone at the top starts with your board.
Guiding the future ready enterprise
NACD’s 2018-2019 survey also found that business model disruption, cybersecurity threats and technology disruption are top concerns for 42 percent, 37 percent and 35 percent of respondents, respectively. “Helping to assess your company’s competitive landscape in terms of both threats and opportunities, and then helping to shape the right strategy to address those should be your board’s greatest contribution,” says Gawrych. “Today, those threats and opportunities are largely digital and driven by technology. You need board members with the experience to guide those efforts.”
For private companies, finding board members who can deliver meaningful digital guidance can be a challenge, especially if you are not in a tech-centric industry. Where to start? Executives at technology companies are one option, but leaders at companies in similar industries who have effectively lead efforts to merge the promise of technology with the operational realities of their business can be an even better fit.
Effectively managing the agenda for board meetings is a key element to getting the right level of strategic support. Too often, even at public companies, seemingly pressing short-term issues can eat up much of the board’s time, leaving little to devote to strategic issues. The right level and focus of communication between board members and your CEO and other business leaders is also a key concern. “You want your board to be a resource for your leaders, to share key ideas, to challenge them when necessary, but you don’t want your board overly involved in operations,” says Gawrych. “Ideally, your board can serve as a think tank to help shape strategy. It’s up to your leadership team to execute it.”
By exploring possible disruptive threats and pushing your company to respond proactively, your board can help transform the threat of disruption into an opportunity. Just as offense is often the best defense, being the disruptor is often the best strategy in today’s digital environment. But threats remain. Cybersecurity and data privacy are major ones.
Boards need to help push companies to look beyond just cyber defense and toward cyber resiliency. The sheer volume and continuing evolution of cyberattacks means that every company is almost guaranteed to face a breach. Companies need to devote as much effort on how such events will be contained and mitigated as they do on how they can be prevented. Data privacy is also a growing concern, both in terms of complying with emerging regulations such as the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and in the more strategic sense of gaining and building consumer trust while still being able to benefit for the growing body of data available to drive business decisions.
The pace of strategic change today’s digital environment demands only heightens the importance of a broadly experienced board. Having a committed and experienced group of business leaders who understand your operations, constraints, competitors and strategy and who are constantly watching for emerging possibilities gives your leadership team a powerful asset to draw on. “Even for the most gifted CEO, it’s almost impossible to both run the business and keep abreast of every development that may affect it,” says Gawrych. “Having a board to help with that reconnaissance, one that can both provide and challenge ideas, that can be the difference between just keeping up and actually getting ahead.”
Ownership shapes board focus
Is your company a closely held family business? A relatively large private company with a variety of ownership interests? A portfolio company for a private equity fund? Because the board’s primary duty is to the owners, how the company is owned should shape the board’s focus and structure. A private equity group usually is working toward an exit strategy in a relatively short time frame, so its focus will be on short-term maximization of overall value. Therefore, the board will have a heavily operational focus and will benefit from directors with that orientation. Family-owned businesses can face complex decisions that balance near-term corporate needs against longer term family concerns. Having board members who understand those dynamics, perhaps a director with specific estate and intergenerational wealth planning expertise, can help integrate family concerns with business strategies. Family businesses also can face the challenge of attracting the right talent without diluting ownership, which requires specialized compensation planning. The right experience matters.
Winning the war for talent
It all takes talent. In NACD’s 2018-2019 survey, private companies identified key talent deficits as the trend most likely to affect them in the coming year. Private companies often can’t match the total compensation packages of larger public competitors, especially in critical areas like technology and innovation. What’s more, what workers value is undergoing a generational shift, with millennials focusing on flexibility and work-life balance, not just money.
While the idea of culture is certainly harder to define than issues like regulatory compliance, technology or even innovation, getting it right has never been more important to the enterprise. Which means your board needs to understand what’s working when it comes to culture and talent and help push your company to incorporate those changes into your policies and practices. A board member with an HR background or that has held a leadership position with a company that has shown truly innovative solutions to the talent problem could provide a vital competitive edge.
Other board basics
Hiring and evaluating your CEO is another critical board function. Your board should provide a broad network and strong insights to help with that—both in the case of a planned transition and in the event of an unplanned change. They should also have the experience to evaluate major corporate initiatives like potential mergers or acquisitions, divestitures, or overseas expansions.
“Your board shouldn’t be just a formality,” says Gawrych. “It should be a powerful strategic weapon.”
National Managing Partner, Private Company Services
+1 954 331 1102